For as long as I have been a school administrator October 1 has been Count Day in Iowa. Simply stated, this is the date where we count the number of students who are in our district. This becomes the base number, and one of the most important variables needed to begin the budgeting process for the next school year. Granted, there are numerous variables that go into calculating the budget. The foundation formula or Aid and Levy Worksheet for example runs some 450 lines. But the biggest number, and most important function in that formula by far is enrollment multiplied by district cost per pupil.
Now, the chances of having perfect attendance on any given day is pretty low. And to assume that all students are going to be present on October 1 is a fool's errand. Some kids are going to be sick, others might be on vacation, or a whole host of perfectly excusable and legitimate reasons may keep them from school that day. But it didn't matter. Because as long as that student has a permanent address in that district and is enrolled in your school, they are counted. At least that is how I have been doing it for more than 20 years. And that is how every administrator in the state is completing the process. It seems reasonable, right?
Everyone tracking the process at this point? As I've stated numerous times in this column, it is never as easy as simply counting the kids. It takes some time to complete and reconcile the numbers, but the execution of the evolution is pretty straight-forward, albeit labor intensive. So, we were all disappointed when during the last legislative session they enacted a new law when they set supplemental state aid that requires schools to execute a second count date. The reason for this new count, at least according to the legislature, is to provide 'more precise funding' to school districts. Noble perhaps, except the evidence suggests that is not the case. Instead, it appears to be a deliberate effort to further erode funding for schools.
You see, this is how it is supposed to work. The two counts are going to be averaged together, the average of which being the base number. My supposition is the second count will be lower across the entire state for a couple of reasons. One of which fits the narrative that was used when launching the voucher program, the second is much more nefarious in my view.
The second count date is January 15. By that time in the calendar, there will be very few, if any school districts still in the first semester. This is important because Iowa law requires school districts to allow seniors to graduate up to one semester early if they have completed their graduation requirements. So those students won't be on that second count. Are there a lot of students who graduate early? Well, we have a decent handful at Hudson that do every year, somewhere between 3-5 students. Extrapolate that across the state and control for district size and see what that looks like. It's somewhere in the vicinity of a $7million to $12.5 million in reduced formula authority statewide from just early graduates alone. Is that a lot? Well, you be the judge. When you set SSA at 2% and claim you have invested $60-$70 million in budget growth and then peel off the graduating seniors it kind of looks like you are playing a shell game.
That isn't great. But, unfortunately it gets worse. Recall the second paragraph above where we reasonably have concluded for as long as anyone can remember that enrollment and residency were the determinant factor when it comes to counting students? Not this time. If the student is not physically in the district on count day, they are not included as part of that second count. One of my colleagues at a recent statewide superintendent meeting gave the following example.
My parents have gifted our family a Disney Cruise and our family will be on that cruise during the second count date. Does this mean I can't count my own kids who are on vacation?
According to the Iowa Department of Education, they cannot be counted. I'm not making this up. It was actually said out loud during a statewide superintendent meeting. Think about this. We are talking about the Superintendent of Schools who will be on a family vacation-and his kids won't be included in this second count date. This is perhaps one of the most absurd and foolish things I have ever heard. So we have to ask ourselves, what are we doing?
Well, many school districts in Iowa have families that travel out of country to spend time with extended family over the holidays. Those vacations routinely span multiple weeks with those students not returning until late January-after the second count date. It leaves you wondering whether this rule was designed with a specific group of families in mind-and whether sweeping everyone else up in the net was simply the price of making it look uniform.
The reality is this in no way will impact family vacations. It will have no penalizing factor on any single demographic in school districts. What it will do though, is impact all demographics. At the end of the day, school funding is supposed to reflect the true costs of educating every child who walks through our doors. Not penalize districts when seniors succeed ahead of schedule or when families spend meaningful time together over the holidays.